The second song was a surprise: a duet, half-English, half-Urdu, with a female voice that threaded through Atif’s like a ribbon. It wasn’t his usual heartbreak ballad but a playful argument about time—how it shifts, slips, and sometimes gives you exactly what you didn’t know you wanted. The bridge featured a delicate oud riff and a moment of silence before Atif’s voice exploded with the kind of raw joy that made Ayaan laugh out loud alone in his apartment.